View Poll Results: New or Old Metallica

**charlesotis** · March 24th, 05:18 PM

Which one do you like more, I say draw the line around their "Load" album

**E-99 king** · March 24th, 05:40 PM

old metallica. I liked master of puppets and ride the lightning more than any of their other albums.

**TonyD** · March 24th, 05:42 PM

Old for sure. I don't hate the new stuff and I do like it in different ways, but in particular all the ones that are silver (the CD's themselves) rule the most.

**Dedomi** · March 24th, 07:22 PM

I like Load and all before, afterwards Garage inc is alright and Reload sucked. Saint Anger is they're worst ever, but they are old and they are trying...

I draw the line just after Load.

**Bose** · March 24th, 08:53 PM

Old Hands Down!!!!!!! Think about it Ride the Lightning, Master of Puppets, Kill Em' All, In[or And(im drawing a complete blank)] Justice for All... Old is tons better then their new stuff

**TonyD** · March 24th, 10:14 PM

Whoa, but I forgot, I love Garage Inc. Good stuff on those two discs. The Merciful Fate Medley rules a lot....11 minutes of metallic goodness.

**cryodude** · March 25th, 07:24 AM

OLD RULES. I just don't feel there new stuff. I think they are trying to hard, they have a lot to live up to.

**Star** · March 25th, 10:26 AM

old is definately better kill em all kicks a$$

**wgpisgod** · March 25th, 10:54 AM

Old for sure.

**Smitty** · March 25th, 01:28 PM

I draw the line with And Justice for all. The black album was good but it was the start of their decline, BTW who was the trendy ass poser that voted for "after load"?

**TonyD** · March 25th, 02:37 PM

Actually, honestly, it'd be more "trendy" to say that the old stuff is better. Notice the side that has more people on it? That'd be a "trend." Therefore, somebody on that side would be more "trendy."

I'm not saying we ALL say it because others do (while some do I'm sure) but just pointing something out. I like the old stuff because I like metal (a lot), and it's better metal.

**fainTB** · March 25th, 04:19 PM

i hate metallica

**HuNtS** · March 25th, 04:50 PM

u did not just say that.......lol j/k but yeah, i definitely like the old stuff a LOT better st. anger just sux compared to the old stuff...

**Targ3tPractic3** · March 25th, 07:07 PM

Old. No question at all. The new stuff isn't nearly as good.

***P4IN7 B4LLS*** · March 25th, 07:50 PM

old definately. i mean cmon...

master of puppets
ride the lightning
and justice for all
black

u cant beat em.... those are IMO the best 4 albums of metallica

**Smitty** · March 25th, 08:51 PM

You chose the Black Album over the Garage days with Green hell? Oh well everybody has an opinion. But other than that I am in total agreement

**Xley** · March 26th, 04:31 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by TonyD246
I like the old stuff because I like metal (a lot), and it's better metal.

**Dedomi** · March 27th, 11:48 AM

Quote:

Originally posted by fainTB
i hate metallica

Why post, why type? Why the HELL even say anything? If you dont like Metallica get the **** outa this topic.

Garage Inc has a lot of good songs
Astronomy
Am I evil
etc

But, it has alot of other, boring songs like Tuesdays Coming and such. Overall the good to bad song ratio is probably like 40-60. 40 being good. I liked it, but you have to make a mixed cd with just the good ones.

**TonyD** · March 27th, 02:31 PM

Tuesday's Gone is a great song, what are you thinking? Skynyrd is sweet, and the Metallica cover is sweet too.

**shocker15** · March 27th, 03:07 PM

Old

Give me fuel Give me fire Give me that which i desire.

View Poll Results: New or Old Metallica

Thread Tools