Paintball Guns and Gear forums banner

1 - 12 of 12 Posts

·
Screaming Koala
Joined
·
4,685 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
Yea, you read it right. They're counter claiming that the RIAA is, infact, wrong.

Last month, the RIAA sued Limewire after Limewire wouldn't agree to simply roll over and pretend the RIAA's interpretation of the Supreme Court decision in the Grokster case was actually what the Supreme Court said. The court actually said that services could be found liable, if they were shown to actively induce infringement. The RIAA and the MPAA pretended this meant that any file sharing network that had unauthorized content was flat-out illegal. Of course, that's a bit of a stretch. So, it already seemed like it would be an interesting case, but now Limewire has hit back even harder with counterclaims accusing the RIAA of antitrust violations, consumer fraud and other misconduct. Specifically, they seem to be making the case that the RIAA only wants to shut down Limewire because it is a competitive distribution mechanism that they cannot control, which helps compete with their monopolistic control on traditional distribution. It's an interesting claim that does make some sense, though the RIAA will simply try to paint Limewire as a tool for "thieves." As with many of these types of cases, there's probably a decent chance that the sides will settle before any decision is made, but in this case, it would be very interesting to see the actual outcome of any lawsuit -- both on the issue of whether or not simply running a file sharing network is inducement and on whether or not there really is an antitrust claim here. If the case does go forward and the RIAA loses on the antitrust issue, it could have a big impact on the traditional labels, and could actually be a catalyst towards forcing them to accept the changing nature of the market. This is becoming a case well worth watching.

http://techdirt.com/articles/20060925/230637.shtml
 

·
Its never lupus
Joined
·
9,169 Posts
Kleivonen said:
if limewire shuts down, can we still use the program on the gnutella network, if its already downloaded on our computer? cuz idk of much else thats compatable with a mac


and im NOT paying 99 cents a song
Acquisition. Google it.

Its about time the RIAA gets hit back. The music industry and audience is changing and this just further shows that fact. The only artists who actually lose money over downloading are the popular ones that already have enough money. It hard to find the less popular stuff on limewire.

Most musicians encourage it. Also there was no noticeable descrease in CD sales when napster was popular. The only reason CD sales have decreased recently is because of the itunes store.
 

·
Cold Fusion...
Joined
·
2,466 Posts
sNoW PIrAnHa said:
Acquisition. Google it.

Its about time the RIAA gets hit back. The music industry and audience is changing and this just further shows that fact. The only artists who actually lose money over downloading are the popular ones that already have enough money. It hard to find the less popular stuff on limewire.

Most musicians encourage it. Also there was no noticeable descrease in CD sales when napster was popular. The only reason CD sales have decreased recently is because of the itunes store.

thanks a ton, its easier then limewire
 
1 - 12 of 12 Posts
Top